itarian regimes, he saw the complete abrogation of personal privacy as their crowning In The Limits of Privacy, Amitai Etzioni, of George Washington Univer -. But in The Limits of Privacy, Amitai Etzioni offers a decidedly different point of view, in which the right to privacy is balanced against concern for public safety and. “Amitai Etzioni’s The Limits of Privacy offers much of what has been missing from contemporary public policy – thoughtful common sense. As a member of.

Author: Malamuro Taulkree
Country: Haiti
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Marketing
Published (Last): 19 July 2005
Pages: 90
PDF File Size: 2.10 Mb
ePub File Size: 6.32 Mb
ISBN: 149-9-23488-534-3
Downloads: 6151
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Maubei

In the studies of specific public policies, and related matters of civic culture and legal doctrines, privach follow, my first call is to demonstrate that there is a problem to begin with, that champions of privacy have not merely engaged in rhetorical excesses but that these excesses have had significant detrimental effects.

Crtics will argue the author seems to readily advocate proceeding with such intrusions. Privacy advocates and their allies have prevented HIV from being treated like other dangerous communicable diseases a trend referred to among etioni as “HIV exceptionalism”. Commutarians argue that policies should consider what is best for the community while simultaneoulsy attempting to protect privacy rights.

ComiXology Thousands of Digital Comics. Given privacy’s great importance to a free people, my colleagues stressed, one should seek new ways to lrivacy it up, not to cast more aspersions about it.

This book combines philosophical discussions with actual issues and then draws its own conclusions. Kindle Cloud Reader Read instantly in your browser. This is a case of Big Bucks, not Big Brother, violating our privacy. The common goods this book focuses on, prjvacy safety and public health, are not two among many, but the mainstays of what are considered practically uncontested common goods. Four Balancing Criteria First, a well-balanced, communitarian society will seek to reduce the scope of priavcy only if it faces a well-documented and macroscopic threat to the common good as opposed to a merely hypothetical danger.

Users can mail in a few drops of blood and a code name and then call for the results. At the conclusion of each chapter, Etzioni shows how a balanced analysis leads to a solution. Individual privacy is sometimes defended as a God-given right in the rising global debate on the issue. The assertion of absolute rights to individual privacy is not as big a concern as the erosion of our expectations for privacy, said Penn law professor Anita Allen-Castellitto. For example, many agree that drug tests should be conducted on those directly responsible for the lives of others, such as school bus drivers.


In still other cases such checkpoints have not been erected, as public authorities have feared being sued.

The treatment of HIV stands out among the major public policies, laws, regulations, and court cases in which privileging privacy has had considerable impact.

It is about our investment in the common good, about our profound sense of social virtue, and about our concern for public safety and public health.

Even the First Amendment, often considered the most absolute value of them all, does not trump all other considerations, which is, of course, the reason shouting “Fire! No one in the neighborhood knew about his pruvacy.

ID Cards and Biometric Identifiers. There’s a problem loading this menu right now. The maitai of your medical records is violated daily when corporations trade that information on the open market. David Brin puts it mildly, in a book entitled The Transparent Society: Because these measures often entail changes in mores, institutions, or habits of the heart rather than laws or constitutionally protected rights, I refer to them in the following discussion as “second criteria treatments.

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Investigation led to the arrest of Jesse Timmendequas, a man who had served six years in prison for two sex offense convictions and lived with two other rtzioni molesters. One based on the notion of equal concern for the common good public health and safety and privacy, rather than according privacy a privileged position.

The phrase “clear and present danger” comes to mind, but for those who are legally-minded it implies a standard that is too exacting for the purposes at hand.

Buy for others

I hope to engage as many of them as possible in a reasoned and moral dialogue on a crucial issue. Without questioning the basic virtue of privacy, this book will show that in several important matters of public safety and health, the common good is being systematically neglected out of excessive deference to privacy. The courts, champions of privacy hold, far from neglecting the public interest, have regularly included careful attention to it in their deliberations. The principle of limiting the intrusiveness of privacy-curbing measures is further illustrated by the example of a national database that contains the names of medical practitioners who have been sued, sanctioned, or otherwise penalized for crimes, misconduct, or incompetence.


Amitai Etzioni argues that individual rights should be protected except when such preservation presents a clear threat to the community welfare. They are applied to each of the five public policies under review here.

A notable exception is a coding in the National Practitioner Data Bank for payment made in settlement of a medical malpractice action, which the National Practitioner Data Bank cautions “shall not be construed as a presumption that medical malpractice has occurred. Etzioni argues that these laws etaioni not do enough to protect children from sex offenders.

Internationally renowned communitarian leader Amitai Etzioni presents a controversial challenge to the fundamental American belief in personal privacy at all costs.

The Limits of Privacy – [email protected]

Indeed, I find that many corporations now regularly amass detailed accounts about many aspects of the personal lives of many millions of individuals, profiles of the kind that until but a few years back could be compiled only by the likes of the East German Stasi or other major state agencies with huge budgets.

The Limits of Privacy by Amitai Etzioni While The New Golden Rule was aimed strictly at academic audiences, The Limits of Privacy speaks to all who care about the moral, legal and policy issues raised by the tension between personal privacy and the common good, especially public health and safety.

There may be some minor differences between this and the published version.